We recently had the opportunity to test ride both the RadWagon 4 eBike and the Trek Fetch+ 2. Both are electric cargo bikes that offer a convenient and eco-friendly way to transport goods, groceries, or even your kids. While both bikes have their strengths, we found that the RadWagon 4 has a slight edge over the Trek Fetch+ 2.
One of the main advantages of the Trek Fetch+ 2 is its impressive cargo capacity. It can carry up to 440 pounds, which is significantly more than the RadWagon 4. This makes it an ideal choice for families or anyone who needs to transport him large or heavy items. The Trek Fetch+ 2 also has a longer range than the RadWagon 4, with a maximum distance of 65 miles on a single charge.
In the following sections of this article, we will throughly explore the specs of each ebike, reveal the results from our tests and give you insights into which ebike is best for you.
VS
Appearance & Design
RadWagon 4: Appearance
Trek Fetch+ 2: Appearance
The RadWagon 4 has a sleek and modern look with a low step-over height, making it easy to get on and off. The cargo area is located at the back of the bike and features a sturdy rear rack. The bike also comes with fenders to keep you dry on rainy days and a kickstand for easy parking. The handlebars are adjustable, allowing for a comfortable riding position for riders of different heights.
The Trek Fetch+ 2 on the other hand has a similar frame design to the RadWagon 4. One big difference is that it has a larger cargo area than the RadWagon 4. The cargo area is spacious and can accommodate up to two children or a significant amount of groceries. The bike doesn’t come with fenders, but you can purchase an aftermarket pair and install it. The handlebars are adjustable and come with ergonomic grips for added comfort.
Both bikes come with Shimano components, which are known for their durability and reliability. The RadWagon 4 has a Shimano 7-speed drivetrain, while the Trek Fetch+ 2 has a 10-speed drivetrain.
Overall, both electric bikes comes with aesthetic frames. The choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference and intended use.
Display and Controls
RadWagon 4: Display
Trek Fetch+ 2: Display
The RadWagon 4 features a monochrome LCD that provides essential ride information such as speed, range, and pedal assist level. This type of display is generally easy to read, even in various lighting conditions. Placing the controls on the left side of the handlebars might offer convenience for riders who prefer to keep their hands on the handlebars while making adjustments. It ensures quick access to important information without needing to shift focus away from the road.
Contrastingly, the Trek Fetch+ 2 offers an LED panel and the intriguing feature of smartphone connectivity. Allowing users to connect their smartphones to the bike opens up possibilities for tracking rides, using navigation apps, and potentially accessing additional features through apps. The inclusion of a phone stand is a thoughtful addition that enhances the practicality of this connectivity.
Deciding which option is better depends on your preferences and usage. If you prioritize a straightforward, easily accessible display with key ride metrics, the RadWagon 4's monochrome LCD could be a reliable choice. However, if you value the ability to integrate your smartphone for extended functionality and connectivity, the Trek Fetch+ 2's LED panel and smartphone compatibility might be more appealing.
Ultimately, the decision should align with how you intend to use the bike and the level of interaction you want with technology during your rides.
Weight and Weight Limits
The Rad Power RadWagon 4 has a total weight limit of 350 pounds, which includes the weight of the rider, cargo, and any accessories. This is a significant increase from the previous model, which had a weight limit of 275 pounds. The Trek Fetch+4, on the other hand, has a weight limit of 440 pounds.
The weight of the bike itself is also an important consideration. The RadWagon 4 weighs 76.7 pounds, while the Trek Fetch+ 2 weighs around 68.35 pounds. It's worth noting that the weight of the bike can affect how easy it is to handle and maneuver, especially when carrying a heavy load.
In terms of carrying capacity, both electric bikes are designed specifically for carrying cargo. They both have large rear racks that can hold up to 120 pounds, and there are also optional front and side racks available for even more storage space.
Overall, both the Rad Power RadWagon 4 and the Trek Fetch+ 2 are capable electric cargo bikes with their own strengths and weaknesses. When it comes to weight and weight limits, the Trek Fetch+ 2 has a higher weight limit and more carrying capacity and it's also slightly lighter than the RadWagon 4. Ultimately, the best choice for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences.
Motor & Power
RadWagon 4: Motor
Trek Fetch+ 2: Motor
The RadWagon 4 and Trek Fetch+ 2 both have powerful motors, but they differ in a few key ways.
The RadWagon 4 is equipped with a geared hub motor that provides 750 watts of power. This motor is located in the rear wheel and provides a smooth and efficient ride. The motor assist on the RadWagon 4 supports pedal- and throttle-assist, which means that the motor can be activated using a button/lever or when the rider pedals the bike.
On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 is powered by a 250W Bosch Performance Line CX motor that provides up to 85 Nm of torque. This motor is located in the center of the bike and provides a more balanced ride. The motor assist on the Trek Fetch+ 2 can be activated by pedaling only (it doesn’t feature a throttle-assist function).
Both bikes have a maximum speed of 20 mph, which is the legal limit for eBikes in most states. However, the RadWagon 4 has a maximum range of 45 miles, while the Trek Fetch+ has a maximum range of 65 miles. This difference in range may not be significant for some riders, but it can make a difference for those who plan to use their eBike for longer trips.
In terms of power, both bikes are capable of carrying heavy loads. The RadWagon 4 has a maximum weight capacity of 350 pounds, while the Trek Fetch+ can carry up to 440 pounds.
Overall, both bikes have powerful motors and provide a smooth and efficient ride. The RadWagon 4 is better suited for those who need the flexibility of both pedal and throttle assist while the Trek Fetch+ 2 is best for those who want to carry heavier loads.
Battery Capacity and Range
RadWagon 4: Battery
Trek Fetch+ 2: Battery
The RadWagon 4 boasts a larger 672Wh battery, which might suggest a potential for greater range. However, upon closer examination, the Trek Fetch+ 2, equipped with a 500Wh battery, takes the lead due to its more efficient drive system.
While the RadWagon 4 offers a respectable 45-mile range, the Trek Fetch+ 2 surpasses it with an impressive 65-mile range. This discrepancy in range can be attributed to the Trek Fetch+ 2's superior drive system, allowing it to make the most of its available energy. This efficiency not only extends the distance riders can travel but also enhances the overall riding experience.
In terms of battery capacity, the RadWagon 4 certainly offers an advantage for users seeking extended rides without the need for frequent recharging. However, the Trek Fetch+ 2's optimized energy utilization showcases the importance of a well-designed drive system in maximizing range. This can be particularly beneficial for those who prioritize long rides without compromising on energy efficiency.
In conclusion, while the RadWagon 4's larger battery might appear advantageous at first glance, the Trek Fetch+ 2's adept drive system and superior range present a compelling argument for its efficiency and suitability for extended rides. When evaluating these two e-bikes, the Trek Fetch+ 2's combination of a 500Wh battery and an impressive 65-mile range stands out as a commendable feat of engineering, offering users an enhanced and more economical riding experience.
Ride Quality & Handling
The RadWagon 4 has a higher stance, which results in a higher standover height and a more aggressive ride. The 22" x 3" tires also provide excellent traction and stability, making it easy to maneuver and control the bike. The RadWagon 4 also has a throttle, which allows us to ride without pedaling, making it a great option for those who want to take a break from pedaling or need to rest their legs.
On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 offers a more upright riding position, which is great for visibility and comfort. It also has a powerful Bosch Performance Line Speed motor, which provides a smooth and powerful ride. The motor is also very quiet, making it easy to enjoy the ride without any distractions.
Both bikes have an electric assist mode, which makes it easy to ride up hills and over rough terrain. The RadWagon 4 has a 750W geared hub motor, while the Trek Fetch+ 2 has a 250W motor. However, we found that both motors provide plenty of power and speed.
In terms of cargo carrying, both bikes are excellent options. The RadWagon 4 can carry up to 350 pounds, while the Trek Fetch+ 2 can carry up to 440 pounds. The Trek Fetch+ 2 also has a longer wheelbase, which provides more stability and makes it easier to carry larger items.
Overall, both the RadWagon 4 and Trek Fetch+ 2 offer excellent ride quality and handling. The choice between the two will ultimately come down to personal preference and specific needs, such as cargo carrying capacity and riding position.
VS
Suspension, Brakes, Wheels & Tires
RadWagon 4: Tires
Trek Fetch+ 2: Tires
Neither of the ebikes is equipped with suspension; both come with rigid forks. While suspension can provide a smoother ride over rough terrain, it might also add weight and complexity. The absence of suspension can be beneficial for urban rides where a rigid frame offers better efficiency and stability.
The RadWagon 4 features 22” x 3” tires, providing a wider contact patch for enhanced stability and traction. This could be advantageous for tackling varied surfaces and maintaining control, especially off-road or on uneven paths. The increased tire width might also contribute to a more comfortable ride by absorbing small shocks.
On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 comes with 20” x 2.35” tires, which are slightly smaller but still substantial. The narrower tires might provide a bit less stability compared to the RadWagon's wider tires, but they could offer better maneuverability and a more nimble feel, especially in urban environments.
The choice between these tire sizes depends on the intended use. The RadWagon's wider tires are likely better suited for those who prioritize stability, off-road capability, and comfort. The Trek Fetch+ 2's slightly narrower tires could excel in urban settings where agility and quick handling are crucial.
In conclusion, the RadWagon 4's wider tires may be more suitable for riders seeking versatile performance across different terrains, while the Trek Fetch+ 2's narrower tires could appeal to those who prioritize urban agility and responsiveness.
Pedal Assist & Throttles
RadWagon 4: Throttles
Trek Fetch+ 2: Pedal Assist
The RadWagon 4 offers a versatile riding experience with both pedal assist and throttle assist options. Riders can choose from 5 different levels of pedal assist, allowing them to customize the level of motor assistance based on their preference and the terrain. Additionally, the bike is equipped with a convenient half-twist throttle, providing riders with an easy way to accelerate without the need for pedaling. Both the pedal assist and throttle assist have a speed limit of 20mph, ensuring a controlled and safe riding experience.
The Trek Fetch+ 2, on the other hand, focuses on pedal assist functionality to enhance the riding experience. With pedal assist, riders can enjoy a seamless integration of motor power with their pedaling efforts. The bike offers a top speed of 20mph through its pedal assist system, catering to a wide range of riding scenarios. However, unlike the RadWagon 4, the Trek Fetch+ 2 does not support throttle assist and is not equipped with a throttle. This design choice emphasizes a more traditional cycling experience, relying solely on the rider's pedaling motion for motor engagement.
In summary, while both the RadWagon 4 and Trek Fetch+ 2 provide pedal assist capabilities up to 20mph, the RadWagon 4 offers an additional layer of versatility with its throttle assist feature. This allows riders to choose between pedal-only riding, pedal assist, or throttle assist, catering to various riding preferences and needs. On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 emphasizes a purist cycling experience by focusing solely on pedal assist functionality.
Portability
Considering the portability aspect, it's important to analyze the weight and wheelbase of both ebikes.
The RadWagon 4 weighs 76.7 lbs, which might pose challenges when it comes to lifting or transporting it, especially if you need to carry it up stairs or load it onto a vehicle. However, its slightly longer wheelbase of 53.76 inches might contribute to a more stable ride.
On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 weighs 68.35 lbs, making it somewhat lighter than the RadWagon 4. This weight reduction could make it more manageable to move around when needed. Additionally, its slightly shorter wheelbase of 53.74 inches might offer slightly better maneuverability, particularly in tight spaces or urban environments.
In our assessment, while the RadWagon 4 provides a more stable ride due to its longer wheelbase, the Trek Fetch+ 2's lower weight and slightly shorter wheelbase could make it a more practical choice in terms of portability. It might be easier to lift, transport, and navigate through various situations.
Pros & Cons RadWagon 4 eBike vs Trek Fetch+ 2
When comparing the RadWagon 4 eBike and Trek Fetch+ 2, there are several pros and cons to consider. Here's a rundown of what we found:
Pros of RadWagon 4
Cons of RadWagon 4
Pros of Trek Fetch+ 2
Cons of Trek Fetch+ 2
Overall, both the RadWagon 4 and Trek Fetch+ 2 have their strengths and weaknesses. The RadWagon 4 is a great option for those on a budget who need a reliable and versatile electric cargo bike. Meanwhile, the Trek Fetch+ 2 offers a premium experience with top-of-the-line components and features, but at a higher price point. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference and individual needs.
Specifications and Features Table
RadWagon 4
Trek Fetch+ 2
Comparing the specifications and features of the RadWagon 4 and the Trek Fetch+ 2 cargo ebikes is crucial when making a decision between the two. Here's a table that highlights some of the key differences between the two bikes:
Specification/Feature | RadWagon 4 | Trek Fetch+ 2 |
|---|---|---|
Motor Type | Hub | Mid-drive |
Battery Size | 672 Wh | 500 Wh |
Ebike Class | Class 2 | Class 1 |
Cargo Capacity | 350 lbs | 440 lbs |
Adjustable Handlebar | Yes | Yes |
Telescoping Seatpost | Yes | Yes |
Front and Rear Lights | Yes | Yes |
Power Levels | 5 | 5 |
Half-Twist Throttle | Yes | No |
Twist Shift | No | No |
Shimano Deore M4100 | No | Yes |
Bench Seat | No | No |
Internal Cable Routing | Yes | Yes |
Post-Mount Disc | Yes | Yes |
Thru Axle | Yes | Yes |
Bosch Smartphonegrip | No | Yes |
Bosch Connect Module | No | Yes |
Bontrager City Pedals | No | Yes |
The RadWagon 4 is a Class 2 electric cargo bike that comes with a powerful hub motor and a 672 Wh battery. It has a cargo capacity of up to 350 lbs and comes with a range of features such as adjustable handlebars, telescoping seat post, front and rear lights, and five power levels. The bike also has a half-twist throttle for easy and smooth actuation of the motor.
On the other hand, the Trek Fetch+ 2 comes with a 500Wh battery. The bike has a cargo capacity of up to 440 lbs and comes with features such as adjustable handlebars, telescoping seat post, and five power levels. It also has a Shimano Deore M4100 for smooth shifting.
In terms of sizing and geometry, both bikes come in different sizes to fit riders of different heights. They are also compatible with a range of accessories such as panniers and cargo drive units.
Overall, both the RadWagon 4 and Trek Fetch+ are excellent electric cargo bikes with unique features and specifications. The choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs.
Overall Recommendation Based on Intended Use
After testing both the RadWagon 4 and the Trek Fetch+ eBikes, we have come to a conclusion on which one is best suited for different types of riders.
For those who prioritize cargo carrying capacity, the Trek Fetch+ 2 is the way to go. With a 440-pound weight limit and a sturdy rear rack, this eBike can handle all of your hauling needs. The battery’s capability also allows for longer rides without having to worry about running out of power. The mid-drive motor provides ample power, making it easy to navigate hills and rough terrain.
On the other hand, if you are looking for an eBike that is more suitable for casual rides around town, the RadWagon 4 may be the better option. It has a sleek design and is available in multiple colors, making it a stylish choice. The drivetrain provides smooth shifting and the bell adds an extra level of safety when riding in crowded areas.
Overall, the Trek Fetch+ 2 is the better choice for those who need to transport heavy cargo and prioritize power and range. The RadWagon 4 is a great option for those who want a more casual and stylish eBike for shorter rides around town.
VS
